The luxury market is driven by both prestige and intense competition. To grow and capture market share, many brands are pursuing mergers and acquisitions. This article reviews two cases: Mytheresa’s acquisition of YOOX NET-A-PORTER (YNAP) and Frasers Group’s failed attempt to acquire Mulberry. It also covers the regulatory challenges related to the blocked Tapestry-Capri merger, showing the complexities in the fashion and luxury industry.

Mytheresa Announcement: Acquisition of YOOX NET-A-PORTER

On October 7, 2024, Mytheresa announced it would acquire YOOX NET-A-PORTER from Richemont for €555 million, aiming to establish a major global digital luxury group. Expected to close in early 2025, the deal grants Mytheresa full ownership of YNAP, debt-free. Richemont, in return, will receive a 33% stake in Mytheresa and a €100 million credit facility to support YNAP.

Strategy and Market Position

Mytheresa’s acquisition centers on enhancing customer engagement and streamlining operations. By integrating luxury divisions across MYTHERESA, NET-A-PORTER, and MR PORTER, each brand retains its identity while sharing resources. This strategy is crucial as affluent consumers increasingly expect personalized shopping experiences.

This integration aims to meet the growing demand for online luxury shopping, which has rapidly expanded. Analysts predict continued growth in luxury e-commerce, and Mytheresa’s access to YNAP’s customer base and products strengthens its position in this market.

Financial Considerations and Outlook

While the outlook appears positive, the acquisition comes with challenges. Richemont anticipates a write-down of YNAP’s net assets by approximately €1.3 billion, reflecting the cash retained at closing. This highlights the importance of effective financial management during the integration process to ensure success.

Mytheresa CEO Michael Kliger expressed optimism, viewing this move as a step toward creating a leading digital luxury group. Richemont Chairman Johann Rupert noted Mythersea’s potential to build on YNAP’s assets, indicating a collaborative approach that could benefit both companies. This shared vision may drive innovation and open new opportunities in luxury e-commerce.

Frasers Group’s Bid for Mulberry

In contrast to Mytheresa’s success, Frasers Group’s attempt to acquire Mulberry illustrates the challenges in the luxury market. On October 23, 2024, Frasers Group, owned by Mike Ashley, withdrew its £111 million ($143.7 million) bid for Mulberry after the board rejected it, highlighting the difficulties of negotiating with established luxury brands.

Despite owning 37% of Mulberry, Frasers Group struggled to influence its governance. A lack of engagement from Mulberry’s board and resistance from major investor Challice made negotiations difficult. Concerns over Mulberry’s financial health increased, as seen in a 6.5% share drop following the bid’s announcement.

Mulberry’s leadership chose to remain independent, valuing existing relationships and governance over Frasers Group’s capital and strategic support.

After the Bid

Frasers Group decided to end the offer period and pursue broader discussions with both Mulberry and Challice. This shift signals a strategy focused on relationship-building rather than aggressive acquisition but also highlights the challenges of preserving brand identity and governance in the luxury sector.

Regulatory Issues: Tapestry-Capri Merger Blocked

Regulatory issues complicate luxury market acquisitions. The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York blocked Tapestry’s $8.5 billion acquisition of Capri Holdings, siding with the FTC over concerns about competition in luxury.

The FTC argued that merging Tapestry’s Coach and Kate Spade with Capri’s Michael Kors would create dominance in the “accessible luxury” handbag market. The court agreed, seeing potential reductions in competition, which could affect pricing and innovation.

Tapestry plans to appeal the ruling, asserting that the merger would enhance competition and benefit consumers. Yet, this situation reflects growing skepticism about consolidations in the luxury sector. The urgency for Tapestry increases as financing for the deal expires in February 2025, raising questions about its future acquisition strategy. The FTC’s decision to block the merger indicates heightened scrutiny of mergers across various industries, highlighting the need to balance consumer interest with market competition.

Conclusion

Mytheresa’s acquisition of YOOX NET-A-PORTER positions it well in digital luxury, while Frasers Group’s failed Mulberry bid illustrates the difficulty of working with established brands.

The blocked Tapestry-Capri merger adds another layer of complexity to luxury sector deals. As brands seek growth through partnerships, aligning visions, governance, and market conditions remains crucial.

In an evolving luxury market, brands must adapt to shifting consumer preferences, regulatory standards, and competitive pressures. The future of luxury acquisitions will hinge on how well brands manage these factors while keeping their identities and satisfying customers.

---

Sources:

1. Mythersea and Richemont sign agreement for Mythersea to acquire YOOX NET-A-PORTER (YNAP). Richemont. https://www.richemont.com/news-media/press-releases-news/myt-netherlands-parent-bv-mytheresa-and-richemont-sign-agreement-for-mythersea-to-acquire-yoox-net-a-porter-ynap/
2. Richemont announces deal to sell online retailer YOOX NET-A-PORTER. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/markets/deals/richemont-announces-deal-sell-online-retailer-yoox-net-a-porter-2024-10-07/
3. Frasers ditches £111m takeover plans for luxury firm Mulberry. Independent. https://www.independent.co.uk/business/frasers-ditches-ps111m-takeover-plans-for-luxury-firm-mulberry-b2634249.html
4. UK’s Frasers walks away from Mulberry bid. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/markets/deals/uks-frasers-walks-away-mulberry-bid-2024-10-23/
5. Frasers Group criticises management of Mulberry, ditches takeover plans. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/business/2024/oct/23/frasers-group-criticises-management-of-mulberry-ditch-takeover-plans
6. FTC blocks Tapestry-Capri merger as Tapestry vows to fight, saying it’s pro-consumer. Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/pamdanziger/2024/10/25/ftc-blocks-tapestry-capri-merger-as-tapestry-vows-to-fight-saying-its-pro-consumer/
7. Tapestry Inc. and Capri Holdings Limited. Federal Trade Commission. https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/cases-proceedings/231-0133-tapestry-inccapri-holdings-limited-matte