Ferrari has made its position unmistakable, its trademarks are not open to reinterpretation. A dispute involving Philipp Plein’s unauthorised use of Ferrari’s trademarks has led to significant penalties, drawing attention from the fashion and automotive industries. Rulings by Italian courts highlight the serious consequences of misusing trademarks, particularly those tied to luxury brands.
The Instagram Posts That Triggered Ferrari’s Legal Action
Philipp Plein’s troubles began with Instagram posts featuring models posing with his clothing and sneakers against a backdrop of Ferrari cars. These posts, intended to promote Plein’s brand, included provocative imagery that Ferrari argued misused its trademarks without consent.
Exploiting Ferrari’s Reputation
The Court of Genoa ruled in favour of Ferrari, stating that Plein’s actions unlawfully exploited the automaker’s reputation for his own commercial gain. The court determined that the posts created a misleading association between the two brands, thereby violating Ferrari’s intellectual property rights.
Penalties for Plein
After the Genoa decision, the Court of Milan imposed even stricter penalties. Plein was ordered to remove all Ferrari-related content from his website, social media platforms, and other online channels.
Additionally, the Milan court fined Plein €300,000 and imposed a €10,000 daily penalty for any delays in compliance. To emphasise its stance on trademark protection, the court also required the ruling to be published in two national newspapers, a rare but impactful measure.
The 2018 Spectacle That Backfired
The roots of the dispute extend to Plein’s 2018 spring/summer runway show, where Ferrari cars appeared prominently. These cars, adorned with Plein’s logos and artistic designs, were at the center of Ferrari’s claims of intellectual property infringement.
Plein defended his actions as a creative tribute to car culture, referencing films like Grease and Fast and Furious. However, the court dismissed this argument, siding with Ferrari’s assertion that the unauthorised use of its trademarks created a deliberate and misleading association with Plein’s brand.
Lessons from Ferrari’s Trademark Defence
Ferrari’s global reputation gives it strong protection under Italian and EU intellectual property laws. This case highlights the risks of using well-known trademarks without authorisation, particularly for commercial purposes. Plein faced substantial legal consequences for its unauthorised use of Ferrari’s trademarks and brand assets, showing Ferrari’s commitment to protecting its intellectual property and maintaining exclusivity.
The case also warns other brands and influencers to respect legal boundaries when engaging with established trademarks. If you plan to use Ferrari, or any brand with a similar level of protection, obtain authorisation before using any assets to avoid unnecessary costs, legal disputes, and damage to your reputation.
Source: